145 So. Main Street • New City, NY 10956

call us


our address

145 So. Main Street
New City, NY 10956

our hours

Monday-Thurs 11:30am-10pm
Friday & Saturday 11:30-11pm
Sunday 12pm-10pm

Petey Wheaty's

Serving the best of the best
hand crafted ice creams, hot foods,
and baked goods in the heart of New City!

Now Featuring

Perfectly Sothern Fried Chicken

What People are Saying...

Ice cream was great!

"Ice cream was great! The staff is very friendly! We will definitely be back to try more options.

Best of luck!!"

— Brie R (Facebook Review)

Last night my family and I visited...

"Last night my family and I visited this place. And we will definitely be going back. We loved the unique flavors. The real ice cream taste. Service was very good.

And to our surprise they also offer food!! Good food. We might try that next."

— Krisber C. (Facebook Review)

With great staff and a large...

"With great staff and a large variety of food and ice cream, Petey Wheaty’s is New City’s next big hit. Best of luck to the owners and can’t wait to come back again soon!"

— Dana M. (Facebook Review)

The BEST ice cream...

"The BEST ice cream in Rockland hands down!! My family and I love love love going here after a long day of work to enjoy some delicious ice cream! We are here way more than we should confess This whole family is also the absolute sweetest! They always wait up for us when we call in our orders and always greet us with a smile and great conversation!!! If you haven’t been here, WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR!?!?"

— Wendy M. (Facebook Review)